Monday, March 26, 2018

Incinerating Presuppositionalism: Year Thirteen

Again we now come to another anniversary of this blog’s inception, marking a full 13 years since its inaugural post in March 2005. While I’d think by now I’d have become accustomed to the increasing rapidity with which the days, months, years and hours of my life pass, I’m still amazed at where all my time goes. For time is life, and life is all.

The same constraints on my time that I was facing a year ago, are still in place today as well. The relatively slow activity on my blog is certainly not a result of a lack of energy on my part, but rather a result of me spending my energies elsewhere. I do intend to keep writing, but I’m not sure how much longer I’ll be writing on presuppositionalism as it seems to have breathed its final breath, so far as I can tell. Perhaps readers are still encountering presuppositionalists out there – if so, feel free to post a link and maybe I’ll take a look.

Here is this past year’s list of entries, starting with last year’s twelfth anniversary posting:

434. Incinerating Presuppositionalism: Year Twelve - March 26, 2017

435. Sye’s Fixation with “Insane” People - April 28, 2017

436. Anderson on the Lowder-Turek Debate - May 8, 2017

437. Andy Bannister on Atheism - June 27, 2017

438. Do Gardens Imply the Existence of Invisible Magic Beings? - July 28, 2017

439. D’oh! - August 28, 2017

440. Christian Hope - September 20, 2017

441. Do Atheists Face a Dilemma Inherent in Atheism? - October 30, 2017

442. ”Where did morality come from?” - November 28, 2017

443. ”What would convince you?” - December 27, 2017

444. Is the Christian God a “Necessary Being”? - January 1, 2018

445. Does Following the Evidence Lead One Over a Cliff? - February 25, 2018

And as always, thanks to the loyal few readers who continue to monitor this blog, read my posts, leave comments, etc. I appreciate your comments and I do always read them, though I simply have too little time to participate in the conversation these days.

by Dawson Bethrick



Blogger Nick said...

Hi Dawson (and Fellow Blog Readers),

I'm new to Objectivism and have read just a few articles (mostly yours). I have a basic orienting question that I have not found addressed, and my internet searches have come up empty.

It appears that a fundamental tenet of Objectivism is that "Existence exists", and it seems that this "existence" means existence outside of consciousness. Thus there are things (in some sense) that are outside of consciousness that then enter into relationship with consciousness. It further appears that the basis of this tenet is "perceptual self-evidence". Assuming this understanding is sufficiently correct, here is my question:

How does one go from perceptual consciousness to knowing that what is perceived is outside consciousness? For example, in a dream I perceive objects that appear to be things outside consciousness, but after I awake I don't usually say these objects (within consciousness) were actually things (outside consciousness). I can apply reasoning in my waking state to justify why the objects of dreams are not things while the objects of my waking state are things, but the tenet appears to be asserted based on "perceptual self-evidence" rather than on reasoning.

I can lay this out more thoroughly, but I will stop there in recognition of my ignorance. Thank you for any response or reference you can give relating to this matter.


March 27, 2018 5:21 PM  
Blogger Ydemoc said...

Hey Dawson,

Happy 13th! Thanks for all the entries — and for continuing to pound out new ones this past year.

Even though I know that there are likely to be fewer entries to pore over in the future, I plan to keep visiting your blog, as there are plenty of older ones to get reacquainted with.

Thank you once again.


March 28, 2018 7:03 PM  
Blogger Jason mc said...

A good year, happy 13th indeed.

April 01, 2018 1:04 AM  
Blogger helen shapiro said...

Thank you very much for this post. Your posts are the useful thing which we all are looking for that kind information.
Seo Services Company In Delhi

April 02, 2018 12:45 AM  
Blogger Robert Bumbalough said...

Hi Dawson, Thanks for all your work. Best Wishes.

Found a Youtube recording of Ms Rand in a Hollywood One interview from 1966.

April 06, 2018 7:54 PM  
Blogger Farooq Appenterprises said...

Healthisgod is the only complete health and wellness website that you may describe as it yours. We created a site that introduces the collection of health and lifestyle information supported by reliable content providers and genuine user reviews. This is a sincere effort on our part to bring forth a user experience which is engaging, moving, and interactive. Visit for more- Health is God

August 13, 2018 12:15 AM  
Blogger sweeti jha said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

August 13, 2018 10:09 PM  
Blogger sweeti jha said...

I think this is a real great article post.Really looking forward to read more. Visit at
Crazy Video Hub

August 13, 2018 10:10 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home